
GameDay Network
Meet Matt Ponatoski: Dual-Sport Phenom and Elite QB Prospect
September 8, 2025
Recruiting Trail
FOOTBALL - BOYS
Explore the story of Matt Ponatoski, a high school athlete who excels in both football and baseball, and his aspirations for multi-sport success.
This segment features Matt Ponatoski, a remarkably talented junior from Archbishop Moeller High School, recognized as the Ohio Gatorade Player of the Year for both football and baseball— a rare double feat. In football, Ponatoski showcased his skills by throwing over 4100 yards with 57 touchdowns, leading his team to a strong season finish. On the baseball diamond, he maintained a batting average of .462 with four home runs. Matt, named one of the Elite 11 quarterbacks after his outstanding performance in the Pro Day Challenge, plans to play both sports in college, with Oregon, Arkansas, and Kentucky as his top choices. Despite potential MLB draft opportunities, Matt is focused on enjoying his senior year and maintaining his competitive edge.